Esau selling his Birthright

copy after Paulus Moreelse, after 1609

Ezau verkoopt zijn eerstgeboorterecht. Jacob en Ezau zitten aan een tafel, Ezau drukt Jacob de hand en reikt naar het bord met linzen. Op de vloer ligt een jachthond. Op de achtergrond Sara en Jacob aan het bed van Isaac.

  • Artwork typepainting
  • Object numberSK-A-3455
  • Dimensionssupport: height 124 cm x width 160.7 cm, outer size: depth 8 cm (support incl. frame)
  • Physical characteristicsoil on canvas

Paulus Moreelse (copy after)

Esau Selling his Birthright (Genesis 27:1-29)

after 1609

Technical notes

The coarsely woven, plain-weave canvas has a horizontal seam at the level of the dog’s head, and has been lined. Cusping is present on all sides except on the left. The reddish brown ground is visible throughout as the paint layers have been applied with a dry brush. The handling is broad with thick impasto.


Scientific examination and reports

  • technical report: W. de Ridder, RMA, 12 januari 1999

Condition

Poor. The entire surface is very worn. There are two vertical folds about one third of the way in from either side. The extensive retouchings and the varnish are discoloured.


Provenance

…; bequeathed to the museum by O.A. Peters, Amsterdam, December 1942

Object number: SK-A-3455

Credit line: O.A. Peters Bequest, Amsterdam


The artist

Biography

Paulus Moreelse (Utrecht c. 1571 - Utrecht 1638)

De Bie was the first author to give Moreelse’s year of birth; the artist’s baptismal record has not come down to us. His father, Jan Jansz Moreelse, was a cooper from Louvain. According to his 17th- and 18th-century biographers, Moreelse studied for two years with Michiel van Mierevelt, probably in Delft, and then spent a long period in Italy, where he received numerous portrait commissions in Rome. None of the paintings executed by Moreelse in Italy are known today. He returned to Utrecht by 1596, when he reportedly joined the saddlers’ guild, to which painters also belonged. In 1602 Moreelse married Antonia van Wintershoven. Because the ceremony took place in the town hall of Utrecht, Moreelse would not have been a member of the Reformed Church at this point. Later, however, he did join that congregation. His first dated painting, a Portrait of a Man is also from 1602.1Domela Nieuwenhuis 2001, II, p. 348, no. SAP2. In the spring of 1611, Moreelse was elected dean of the saddlers’ guild and in September of the same year he became the first dean of the newly founded Guild of St Luke. He held this post again in 1612, 1615 and 1619. Twenty-eight pupils are recorded as having trained with Moreelse from 1611 on, more than with any other guild member. Together with Abraham Bloemaert, Moreelse was also one of the principal teachers at the drawing academy set up in Utrecht some time after the painters’ guild gained independence. Among Moreelse’s pupils were Dirck van Baburen (1594/95-1624), Pieter Portengen (c. 1612-43) and Jan ter Borch (?-1676). Two of his sons, Johan (after 1602-34) and Benjamin (before 1629-51), also became painters, and one of his daughters is reported to have assisted Moreelse with the execution of a portrait.

Moreelse was chiefly active as a portrait painter. In addition to his many portraits of Utrecht’s leading citizens, he received commissions from court circles, such as the 1621 Portrait of Sophia Hedwig, Countess of Braunschweig-Wolfenbüttel, as Caritas, with her Children.2Apeldoorn, Paleis Het Loo; illustrated in Braunschweig 2000, p. 60. Moreelse’s 1616 Officers and other Civic Guardsmen of the IIIrd District of Amsterdam, under the Command of Captain Jacob Gerritsz Hoyngh and Lieutenant Nanningh Florisz Cloeck (SK-C-623) is the only civic guard piece by a Utrecht painter to have survived. Moreelse also painted histories and genre pieces, and is credited with introducing the single-figure shepherdess into Dutch painting. His activities as an architect include a plan for enlarging Utrecht (executed posthumously in 1663) and the design of the Catherijnepoort (1621-25; destroyed), one of the town gates. After having supported Prince Maurits’s dismissal of Utrecht’s town council in 1618, Moreelse was given a seat on the new town council, which he occupied until his death. He also served as churchwarden of the Buurkerk, headman of the civic guard, an alderman, and chief treasurer of Utrecht. Paulus Moreelse died on 6 March 1638 and was buried in the Buurkerk.

Jonathan Bikker, 2007

References
Van Mander 1604, fol. 280v; De Bie 1661, p. 131; Von Sandrart 1675 (1925), pp. 171, 178; Houbraken I, 1718, p. 49; Hoevenaar 1778, p. 9; Swillens 1926; De Jonge 1938, pp. 1-7, 139-53 (documents); Bok in Utrecht-Braunschweig 1986, pp. 322-25; Bok in Amsterdam 1993, pp. 311-12; Bok in San Francisco etc. 1997, p. 386; Domela Nieuwenhuis 2000; Domela Nieuwenhuis 2001, I, pp. 13-60, 203-50 (documents)


Entry

The scene in the foreground shows Esau selling his birthright to his brother Jacob for a bowl of pottage. In the background, Isaac blesses Jacob (Genesis 27:1-29).

Received by the museum as a Paulus Moreelse in 1942, the painting was considered a copy after a print (RP-P-OB-5354, see fig. a) by Willem van Swanenburgh II in the 1976 catalogue of the Rijksmuseum’s painting collection and more recently by Domela Nieuwenhuis.3Coll. cat. 1976, p. 398, no. A 3455; Domela Nieuwenhuis 2001, II, p. 533, no. SRH148-1-1. According to the inscription on Van Swanenburgh’s print, which reads ‘P. Moreelse invent. 1609 // W. Swanenburgh sculp. et exc.’, Moreelse was responsible for the design. Neither a drawing nor a painting of this subject by Moreelse now exists. The composition of Van Swanenburgh’s print is in the same direction as that of the present painting, which indeed suggests that it served as the copyist’s model. It cannot be ruled out, however, that there once was a painting by Moreelse and that the design for Van Swanenburgh’s print was reversed in order to retain the direction of the composition in that painting. Significantly, the present painting does not follow the print in all aspects; the architecture is somewhat different and a window with a view onto some houses has been placed behind the figures of Jacob and Esau.4As pointed out in Domela Nieuwenhuis 2001, II, p. 533. The print shows more of Jacob’s drapery on the left, but the lack of cusping on this side of the painting indicates that the canvas was probably cut down here. More telling, is the fact that, although qualitatively not up to Moreelse’s standards, the painting reproduces Moreelse’s style; the copyist would not have been able to create an imitation of Moreelse’s style from Van Swanenburgh’s print.

Jonathan Bikker, 2007

See Bibliography and Rijksmuseum painting catalogues
See Key to abbreviations and Acknowledgements

This entry was published in J. Bikker (ed.), Dutch Paintings of the Seventeenth Century in the Rijksmuseum Amsterdam, I: Artists Born between 1570 and 1600, coll. cat. Amsterdam 2007, no. 222.


Literature

Domela Nieuwenhuis 2001, II, p. 533, no. SRH148-1-1, with earlier literature


Collection catalogues

1976, p. 398, no. A 3455; 2007, no. 222


Citation

J. Bikker, 2007, 'copy after Paulus Moreelse, Esau Selling his Birthright (Genesis 27:1-29), after 1609', in J. Bikker (ed.), Dutch Paintings of the Seventeenth Century in the Rijksmuseum, online coll. cat. Amsterdam: https://data.rijksmuseum.nl/20025765

(accessed 20 December 2025 18:38:58).

Figures

  • fig. a Willem van Swanenburgh II after Paul Moreelse, Esau Selling his Birthright, 1609. Engraving, 280 x 364 mm. Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-P-OB-5354.


Footnotes

  • 1Domela Nieuwenhuis 2001, II, p. 348, no. SAP2.
  • 2Apeldoorn, Paleis Het Loo; illustrated in Braunschweig 2000, p. 60.
  • 3Coll. cat. 1976, p. 398, no. A 3455; Domela Nieuwenhuis 2001, II, p. 533, no. SRH148-1-1.
  • 4As pointed out in Domela Nieuwenhuis 2001, II, p. 533.